Birth-control pills are constantly in the news with various side effects from their prolonged use coming to light every single day. Where does that leave you if you’re not looking to conceive? Natural birth-control methods have been used for generations, yet not all of them are equally effective. So which ones should you opt for?
Should You Even Consider Natural Birth Control Methods?
While natural birth-control methods might not be as effective as commonly used artificial methods like male or female condoms or birth-control pills. But, if any of the modern Fertility Awareness-Based Methods (FABM) are followed accurately, the protection can be as much as 97–99 percent.1
What you should know, however, is that if you make an error in your calculations or take a misstep, the protection that may have been 98–99 percent drops to just about 75 percent or lower, depending on how far off your accuracy is.2 While protection in the high 90s is good enough for most, if you need to improve the effectiveness of the method, be doubly sure to follow all the rules. Besides this, you might want to consider a different approach if
- You have a medical condition that could pose a risk to the child if you got pregnant
- You have irregular periods
- You’re on a medication that disrupts production of cervical mucus
- You’ve recently stopped taking hormonal contraception
- You’ve recently had a miscarriage or abortion
- You’ve recently given birth or are breastfeeding
- You travel through different time zones
- You have a vaginal infection such as thrush or STI
- You’re a heavy drinker
The above-mentioned factors could lower the effectivity of this form of contraception or affect your health adversely. Besides, do remember, while these natural birth-control methods might protect you against conceiving, they do not deflect sexually transmitted diseases. So if you are not in an exclusive monogamous sexual relationship, or are concerned that either of you might be carrying an infection of some kind, you would do well to also use a barrier like a condom.
Temperature And Cervical Secretion-Monitoring Method
These options are examples of FABM. The temperature method involves the use of a basal thermometer which indicates a small rise in body temperature after ovulation. Do note that ear and nose thermometers are not accurate enough for this method. The method involves taking your temperature every morning, ideally at the same time, before you get out of bed and especially before you eat or drink anything.
For 3 days in a row, your temperature might be higher than all of the previous 6 days. This increase in temperature is very small, generally around 0.2 C (0.4 F). It’s likely that at this point, you’re no longer fertile.
The cervical secretion-monitoring method, meanwhile, involves keeping a check on the change in the amount and texture of your cervical secretions (cervical mucus) during different times in your menstrual cycle. To do this, gently insert your middle finger into your vagina, pushing it up to around your middle knuckle.
For the first few days after your period, you might notice that your vagina is dry and doesn’t produce a lot of mucus. As
Combining these two methods has been found to prevent pregnancy. In fact, one study found that it is an effective option for family planning/birth control. During the fertile days, intercourse must be done with some form of birth control or protection. Alternatively, abstinence may be practiced for those days. Of the women enrolled in the study, only 1.8 in every 100 became pregnant over a 13-cycle window. Here, too, the researchers emphasized that effectiveness depends on adhering to the guidelines for observations/tracking of these parameters.3
2. Calendar-Based Method
You could also determine your most fertile days by tracking your menstrual cycle closely. The modern FABM way of doing this is called the Standard Days Method. If you’re someone with a cycle of 26–32 days, this calendar-based method may work for you. What it does is to spot the fertile window, occurring between days 8 and 19 of your cycle. This generally refers to 7 days before your ovulation and 2 days after, when you’re most likely to get pregnant. Once you have zeroed in on the exact dates, you need to either abstain from having sex on these days or use a suitable contraceptive.4 In one study of the method across the Philippines, Peru, and Bolivia over 13 cycles,
The only caveat here for this method is that if a woman’s cycle is irregular or unpredictable, the accuracy and therefore effectiveness of natural birth-control drops. As such, you could combine this method with the temperature and cervical secretion-monitoring method, both of which are generally considered more effective, as seen also in the pregnancy rates in the studies mentioned.
3. Using Fertility Tests
This approach relies on easy-to-use home kits that generally contain a device that can tell you what your most fertile days are. This is done by measuring the levels of luteinizing hormone or estrogen metabolites in your urine and requires you to record the beginning of her cycle, i.e the first day of your menstruation and continue recording each day until the 6th day when you will be asked
That said, besides being expensive, the warning period might not be enough to prevent pregnancy and doesn’t look at the status of cervical mucus. Hence, it might be ideal to combine this method with the cervical secretion-monitoring method monitoring method to fine-tune your observations.
4. Lactational Amenorrhoea Method (LAM)
This method applies to breastfeeding mothers who breastfeed exclusively (only feed your baby breast milk) and have babies that are under 6 months of age. Post-childbirth, exclusive breastfeeding leads to the lack of menstruation in women. Both these factors lead to temporary infertility that some women use as a form of contraception.
When used correctly and consistently, less than 2 in 100 women who use this method will get pregnant in the first 6 months. However, do take care to use the method correctly and be sure not to feed your baby other foods because this may reduce your lactation. That said, it’s important to note that this method becomes unreliable when
- Breastmilk is substituted with other foods or liquids
- Your baby turns 6 months old
- You have a period
Additionally, it is possible for you to get pregnant before your periods start again since women generally ovulate 2 weeks before their period.10
This form of contraception refers to lovemaking without penetration into a vagina or anus. Partners can be sexual, intimate, and even orgasmic without engaging in intercourse. Hence, no semen, vaginal fluids, or blood is shared between them, making it an effective way to prevent pregnancy.11
6. Herbal Medications
Herbs are also believed to be highly effective at reducing fertility in order to naturally and safely prevent pregnancy. Some herbs may affect the ovary, while others act upon the uterus, affect normal hormone production, or block certain hormones. Some herbs also have the ability to interfere with implantation and are useful as an emergency contraceptive. A few of these herbs are as follows:
- Queen Anne’s Lace (Daucus carota): Also known as wild carrot, Queen Anne’s Lace can be taken on as needed basis, making it useful for women who have sex infrequently. Research suggests that terpenoids in the seed block crucial progesterone synthesis in pregnant animals, which disrupts the implantation process, or if a fertilized egg has implanted for only a short period, it will cause the egg to be released without developing.12 To try this method, eat 1 teaspoon of these seeds within 8 hours of unprotected intercourse and continue the course for a week. Be sure to thoroughly chew the seeds for maximum effectiveness.
- Neem: Neem can be used in three different forms for birth control -neem leaves, neem oil, and neem leaf extract. Neem oil kills sperm in the vagina within 30 seconds and remains active for five hours. It causes no irritation or discomfort like the chemical based spermicidal foams do. In addition, neem oil acts as a lubricant and it may also offer some protection from vaginal and sexually transmitted diseases. To try this method, use a water-based vaginal lubricant with ten percent neem oil added. Apply before intercourse to give the surface of the vaginal wall time to become coated with the material. If there was no neem lubricant available during intercourse, applying the lubricant soon after intercourse will prevent implantation.13
- Papaya: Unripe papaya has been used traditionally to prevent or terminate pregnancies. A ripe papaya cannot be used as it loses the phytochemicals that interfere with hormones. The papaya seeds can kill sperms, hence a daily intake of papaya seeds can decrease the sperm count in a healthy male. According to research, the seeds of Carica papaya have been experimentally found to inhibit spermatogenesis in males.14
There are several other herbs, which have partially or in combination with other natural birth control methods, reported to be similarly effective as a contraceptive. However, we have omitted them merely due to the lack of potential research regarding their efficacy. Do not continue using a herb if you start developing problems and also never increase the dosage of herbs more than the required amount. You should never disregard verified advice from a healthcare provider, regarding safety and efficacy of these natural birth control methods.
7. The Pull-Out Method
Also known as coitus interruptus or withdrawal, the pull-out method is one in which the man withdraws or pulls out his penis from his partner’s vagina before ejaculating. This method requires the man to keep his semen away from the woman’s genitalia while ejaculating. This method prevents fertilization by hindering any contact between the sperm and the egg.15
While this is an easy, low-cost method, it relies heavily on the consistency and self-control of the man, lack of which can lead to pregnancy. In addition to this, the method does not take into account pre-ejaculatory fluid which doesn’t usually contain sperm but can sometimes contain a few. It might also pick up any sperm left in the urethra from a previous ejaculation. Hence, it is considered to be one of the least effective natural birth-control methods because it depends on the man’s ability to withdraw before he ejaculates. However, its effectivity goes up to 73 percent if used correctly.16
|↑1||Pallone, Stephen R., and George R. Bergus. “Fertility awareness-based methods: another option for family planning.” The Journal of the American Board of Family Medicine 22, no. 2 (2009): 147-157.|
|↑3||Frank-Herrmann, P., J. Heil, C. Gnoth, E. Toledo, S. Baur, C. Pyper, E. Jenetzky, T. Strowitzki, and G. Freundl. “The effectiveness of a fertility awareness based method to avoid
|↑4, ↑8||Manhart, Michael D., Marguerite Duane, April Lind, Irit Sinai, and Jean Golden-Tevald. “Fertility awareness-based methods of family planning: a review of effectiveness for avoiding pregnancy using SORT.” Osteopathic Family Physician 5, no. 1 (2013): 2-8.|
|↑5||Arévalo, Marcos, Victoria Jennings, and Irit Sinai. “Efficacy of a new method of family planning: the Standard Days Method.” Contraception 65, no. 5 (2002): 333-338.|
|↑6||Monitoring Your Hormones. Marquette University.|
|↑7||Smoley, Brian A., and Christa M. Robinson. “Natural family planning.” American family physician 86, no. 10 (2012).|
|↑9||Fehring, Richard J., Mary Schneider, Kathleen Raviele, and Mary Lee Barron. “Efficacy of cervical mucus observations plus electronic hormonal fertility monitoring as a method of natural family planning.” Journal of Obstetric, Gynecologic, & Neonatal Nursing 36, no. 2 (2007): 152-160.|
|↑10||Natural family planning (fertility awareness). NHS.|
|↑11||What is outercourse? Columbia University.|
|↑12||Riddle, John M., 1997. Eve’s Herbs – A History of Contraception and Abortion in the West., Cambridge, Ma., Harvard University Press.|
|↑13||Upadhyay, Shakti N., Charu Kaushic, and G. P. Talwar. “Antifertility effects of neem (Azadirachta indica) oil by single intrauterine administration: a novel method for contraception.” Proceedings of the Royal Society of London B: Biological Sciences 242.1305 (1990): 175-179.|
|↑14||Sinha, Rajiv K., and G. S. Nathawat. “Anti-fertility effects of some plants used by the street herbal vendors for birth control.” Ancient science of life9.2 (1989): 66.|
|↑15||Family Planning Module: 4. Natural Family Planning (NFP) Methods. The Open University.|
|↑16||Is pulling out safe? Columbia University.|